"I know. I feel bad about that."
Protecting themselves from perceived threats that's what. Part instinctual, part learned(nature vs. nurture anybody?), we all tend to get defensive when a sensitive part of us (our insecurity, our fears, our wounds from previous experiences, our lack of confidence, etc...) is touched or poked at. It is perfectly normal to be defensive from time to time. Everybody is not privileged to dive into your life, your flaws, your issues, real or imagined. It takes a certain type of relationship, hopefully filled with trust so that another may go there.
I call this series Marital Mayhem because it has to do with patterns that can exist within marriages that create trouble. The type of trouble when unchecked can destroy relationships and marriages. How is being overly defensive damaging? The three areas that come to mind are a type of 'backlash' that is quite intense, angry, seemingly random. Another is the 'I am not responsible' defensiveness that tends to throw it back in your face that you have the problem. The third doesn't look defensive but it is very unhealthy, the 'it's all my fault' taking too much responsibility when really the person is just trying to get the other person off their back.
The backlash comes out of left field in that we can touch on some one's issue(s) without really knowing it until they freak out at you. Then you know. Usually though, it really wasn't anything you did, it was something(s) done well before you that has caused your spouse to be so abruptly cranky and fierce. Your crime was that you stumbled upon it by accident but are now the recipient of the angst that really was meant for whomever hurt them. When a person doesn't want to hear or accept that you meant them no harm or meant to cause them such pain but talk to them about an area of their life that needs addressing(we all have them), you got trouble. If some area is so painful that they can't see that you are a friend and not a foe then over time if it does not change you have Mayhem. Withholding trust in any one area over years of being together damages intimacy. The you can go there, and there but not THERE does not fit with the marriage relationship. It can be worked out over time but it is a pattern worth noting and addressing.
The throw back, as I like to call it is a counter attack. When feeling defensive, it can help throw off your spouse by blaming them for the same thing or bringing up something else. The whole purpose is to change the subject and to get the spot light off of you and on to them. The person who uses the "throw back" probably struggles with taking responsibility for their actions and also has a hard time saying sorry. When you approach your spouse with any sort of criticism or question of what they are doing or even wanting to talk to them about something you are concerned about, you get throw back. There can be no growth of intimacy if you and your spouse are not willing to admit wrongs, seek forgiveness or taking responsibility for one's own actions. Mayhem within your marriage is a reality.
Lastly, "it's all my fault" tactic of defensiveness seems really less defensive than it is. A person is taking responsibility right? Well, maybe. Sometimes it is easier to say sorry than to disagree. Avoiding confrontation can be done a number of ways but constantly saying your sorry can buy time. It usually gets the other person off your back. The problem with this "admission" is that it can be a cover for deeper resentment that is unspoken. They aren't sorry. They just don't know how to communicate within a conflict. Nothing is going to change WITHIN them, only the outward behaviors and now they are managing you. The unspoken or "stuffed down" disagreements will create much Mayhem when they and you least expect it. Anger has a way to make a person do and think some very irrational things that they justify easily. Anger is a intimacy killer. Very difficult to "get close" to someone emotionally when you are mad at them all the time.
I have been there. I am not a counsellor, but I am someone who used defensiveness to my and my 1st marriage's detriment. I am a Relationship Coach, and I can help. Contact me shawn@coachingthrough.com.
Shawn